Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout042-150-005BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA December.13, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board.of Supervisors' Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Consent Agenda IV: Business 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan. 2. Status Report -. Code Amendments and Overlay Zone. 3. Status Report. - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville.Municipal. Airport Environs.' 4. Discussion of letterhead design. 5. Business -from the Floor - (Presentations -will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking - Action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) V. Correspondence VI. Referrals to Staff and Formation of. Committees. VII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for January 10, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA November 8, 1989 I TIME: 9.:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of September 13, 1989 Meeting IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Status Report - Chico.Municipal Airport.Environs Plan. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone. 3. Status,Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 4. Discussion of letterhead design. 5. Discussion - Compatibility of -zones with non- compatible uses permitted by Use Permit. 6. Business from the Floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it, is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees. VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for December 13, 1989. 4 e , BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND-USE.COMMISSION AGENDA °f September, 13, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance , II Roll Call ' III. Approval of Minutes of August 9., 19.89 meeting IV. Consent Agenda '# V.. Business 1. Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan - Review. 2. -Status Report - Airport;Zone, Code Amendments, and, Overiay Zone. 3. Status Report - Review of.City of Oroville General -Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. H 4. Discussion of letterhead design:. r • 5. Business from the Floor �.-° (Presentations will be ' limited to three minutes. "The Airport. Land Use Commission is prohibited by.State Law from -taking' Action on any item presented if it is not listed ' . on.the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees. VIII. Announcements 1.' Next meeting is,scheduled.for October 11, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA 1 August 9, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m. _ PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Orovilie, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of July 12, 1989 meeting IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone.. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity. - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs.. 4. Discussion of letterhead design. 5. Business from the Floor - (Presentations will be limited to. three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is snot listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees. VIII. Announcements 1. 'Next meeting is scheduled for September 13, 1989.' BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA JULY 12, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m., PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of June 14, 1989 meeting IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs'Plan Review. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and .Overlay Zone. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville-General .Plan conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 4. Business from the floor _ (Presentations will.be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees z, VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled.for August 9, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION CORRECTED AGENDA jJuly_14, _1989___.jl TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room County Administration 25'County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance H. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of May 10, 1989 meeting IV. Consent.Agenda V. Business 1. Project Review - Tentative Subdivision Map for Sierra Eaton Road and Floral Avenue in the City of Chico. 2'. Status Report Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review.. 3. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone. 4. Status Report — Review of City of Oroville General Plan conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 5. Business from the floor _ (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is not listed on-the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for July 12, 1989.. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION Agenda May 10, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration Center 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of February 8, 1989 meeting IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Election of Officers 2. Discussion - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Enforcement. and Implementation. 3. Discussion —Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone. 5. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 6. Business From the Floor -,(Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda). VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for June 14, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION * * * NOTICE'* ;The March 8, 1989 meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission has been cancelled. The next meeting will be April 12, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA February 8, 1989 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration Center 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of,,October 12, 1988 & November 9, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Status Report — Airport Zone Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone. 2. Status Report - Chico Municipal -Airport Environs Plan Review. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 4. Report - Expiration of Commissioner Stevens' Term on May 1, 1989. (Appointed by the Airport Manager's Association). 5: Business from the Floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to * Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for March 8, 1989.- BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION * * * NOTICE,*.,*.* The January 11, 1989 meeting of the Airport Land Use. Commission has been cancelled. The next meeting will be February.8, 1989. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION NOTICE The December 14-, 1988 meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission has been cancelled. The next meeting will be January 11, 198.9. R. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION ' Agenda " November 9, 1988 , TIME:. 9:00• a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration Center �. 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance_.. II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes- of° October 12; 1988 meeting 'IV. Consent Agenda s , V. Business N 1. Status: Report"---Airport"Zond—, Code! -Amendments; and Overlay Zone. 2. Status Report- Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. - 3: Discussion.- - 1988 ,,Aviation Element Update, Supplement' to -the 1986 Butte County Regional. Transportation Plan. 4. Business From the Floor - (Presentations will be - limited to three minutes. The' Airport Land Use . Commission is prohibited ,by State Law from taking " action,on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda). - VI. Correspondence - VII.. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting scheduled for,December 14, 1.988. x { BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION Agenda October 12, 1988 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room , County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville,-CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of August 10, 1988 , IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. AZ Code Amendment, including private, commercial and'ag (base) airports. 2. Review�of Rezone frorr SR -3 (Suburban -Residential, 3 acre -parcels) to PUD (Planning Unit Development) near Chico Municipal Airport- Thomas Reed. 3. State Report.- Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4. Review of City of Orov.11e General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 5. Review of Pre -Application for Federal Assistance for Chico. Municipal Airport. 6. Business from the floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by -State Law .from taking action on any item presented if itis not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for November 9, 1988. •y _ r i .... ......... Ar- utte e'®un� � • , 'I LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY PLANNING COMMISSION 7'COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE,_CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 PHONE: 538-7601 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION , t•~: r * * * .NOTICE The September 14, 1988 meeting of the. Airport Land Use .Commission has' been cancelled. The next meeting will be October 12, 1988 at 9:00 a.m. t • .. ' .f 7. �.I y r f if . 3 ... ..... ... uite Count q LAND OF N A"T U 'R A L WEALTH AND BEAUTY \' - ., PLANNING COMMISSION TIME: PLACE: VIII. 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE- OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 PHONE: 538-7601 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA' August 10, 1988 9:00 a.m.' Board.of Supervisor's Room County Administration Center 25 County Center. Drive .Oroyille;)CA'6959'65 Pledge'of Allegiance Roll Call Approval of Minutes'of July 13,'1988 consent Agenda Business 1. Revi ew of Tentative Subdivision Map for Ron Caporale, AP#042-15-0--005,019 in,the Rdnchaero Airport area. 2. Status Report Paradise Airport & Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning. 3. -AZ_Code Amendment, including private, commercial and .ag -(bas'e) airports. 4. Business'from the Floor (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) Correspondence Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees Announcements 1. Next meeting scheduled for September 14, 19,88. -- . utte Count - s LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY PLANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 PHONE: 538-7601 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA JULY 13, 1988 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room. County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of April 13, 1988 and June 8, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Election of. -Second Vice Chairman for 1988-89 2. Status -Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning. 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4.' Review of City of Oroville..General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 5._. AZ. Code Amendment, including private, commercial and ag (base) -airports. 6. Business from the floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. -The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from -taking Action.on'any item presented if it is.not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII_ Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for -August 10, 1988.. i BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT'LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA June 8, 1988 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room ' County Administration " 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call , III. Approval.of Minutes of April 13, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Election of Chairman and Vice Chairman for 1988-89 2. Review of .Tentative'Subdivision Map - Ron Caporale, AP 042-15-0-005, 019, Ranchaero approach zone. 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4. Status Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning. 5. AZ Code Amendment, including private, commercial and ag (base) airports. 6. Business from the floor - (Presentations .will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation'of Committees VIII. Announcements . BUTTE, COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE•COMMISSION ' AGENDA April 13,`1988 TME"it 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room - County Administration 25 County Center Drive OtdVille, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II . Roll -Call Approval of Minutes of February 10, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda• V. Business 1. Discussion - Statement of Economic Interests Forms. •t 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning. 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4. Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs. 5. Business from the floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking Action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence_ VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation -.of Committees VIII. •Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for May 11, 1988. 8 8 j C* t I i -1,1 A 00: El I T ,)v i -JO (t 3:) �Jftflo—) AD -T TI i- abn--)pA An9vno,, v f J)bllwelooM in E,nf, j-liocj-11A - E or,lcl Ptiol"vfIS J*7,oq:fiA YJ i 1 1"! 1 t t rl) f L i c J i .2, 1 w 1 v i) I $11r+3 i V,70 ' ao -I'lAk f,6c, i o r. fim fi,f r i "d 1, .f i w no i J 15 j !-, �9,- o 1-1 -1,-) o f wol''t I b o 3n7,l j -,i ro i A VP :, -, i j n -4 1 if j o b t -f 0 4"l-oxi k,,!*,6,'l -vd f),q.lir-jf;dwiq r! i. anifeaimato,) :11 li �l 7::tl aq, wi4J i yfI6 11CA-tJ'A TV 1,0 Ol 1, IV .880.11 U y6l; 1101 1-;Jflfb0d.,m ;i I Imo_ - BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA March 9,1988 TIME:. 9:OO a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room County Administration 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II: Roll Call r III. Approval of Minutes of February 10, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Discussion - Statement of Economic Interests Forms 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs* 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. 4. Review of City of Oroville General Plan -Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs 5. Business from the floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes.' The.Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from.taking Action on any item.presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence, ' VII. Referrals to Staff and.Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is.scheduled for.April 13, 19'88. • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION CORRECTED_ AGENDA February 10, 1988 TIME: 9:OO'a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room County Administration Center 25 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of January 13, 1988 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Public Hearing - Proposed Negative Declaration regarding environ- mental impact and adoption of the Ranchaero Airport Environs Plan for that property located within one -mile of the Ranchaero Airport runway located at -the end of Oak Park Avenue, approximately one-half mile west of Rose Avenue, west of Chico. 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport Environs 3. Discussion of Commercial Airport Zoning and Request to the Butte County Planning Commission to initiate Zoning for the Ranchaero and Paradise Airports., 4. Discussion - SB 263 5. Discussion of Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan and initiation of Review. 6. Discussion - City referrals of Airport related projects. 7. Business from the Floor - (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is prohibited by State Law from taking action on any item presented if it is not listed on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled for March 9, 1988. jy BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION AGENDA -January 13, 1988 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: Board of Supervisor's Room County Administration Center' • 25 County Center Drive Oroville,.CA 95965 I. Pledge of Allegiance II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes of December. 9, 1987 IV. Consent Agenda V. Business 1. Status Report - Ranchaero ALUP 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport Environs 3. Business from the Floor, (Presentations will be limited to three minutes. The Airport Land Use Commission is.prohibited,by State Law'from taking action -on any.item..presented if it isnot listed. on the agenda.) VI. Correspondence VII. Referrals to Staff and Formation of Committees VIII. Announcements 1. Next meeting is scheduled,for February 10, 1988. s 14 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 13, 1989 .The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:05 a.m. on December 13, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Rossas, Walter, Lambert, Franklin, Crotts, Lando and Chairman Stevens Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes II. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. IV. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Commissioner Lando said that Becker McClintock and Associates have been selected to.,prepare the Airport Land Use Plan. He said federal funds will be'used to fund the study and that at this time the consultants are updating the scope of work. He said the work will probably not get underway until March, but that the Plan will be made more extensive. Commissioner Lando said that he will have a status report in March. 2. Status Report - Code Amendments and Overlav zone Staff said there was nothing new to report at this time, however, they did receive correspondence from the City of Chico regarding the proposed policies and that some of the -wording on the proposed building height limits and approach zones may need to be amended. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - December 13, 1939 There was a brief discussion on the building height limit. Staff said that the wording will be changed in order to clear up the confusion regarding slopes, so that there will be no question as to height limits being a part of the approach surface regulations. Chairman Stevens requested that this item be placed on the agenda for January. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Commissioner Rossas discussed the draft plan and said that it was nearing completion and that it would then go before the Oroville City Council. Commissioner Rossas said that the draft plan was for a 10 million dollar improvement project and that it would not be happening for a long period of time, but that the City would be applying for all of the phases at one time, hopefully by January 1, 1990. Mr. Jones, member of the audience, had a question regarding his hanger. Commissioner Rossas said that the current intention was that nothing would be removed until it had worn out. Chairman Stevens requested that this item be placed on the agenda for January. 4. Discussion of Letterhead Desian Commissioner Walter brought some pictures of several airplanes for the Commission to review and said that he would not object to anything the Commission would want to do., but that he has no particular interest or desire to getting the letterhead. Commissioner Lando said that he agreed with Commissioner Walter and also said that a lot of money should not be spent. Commissioner Rossas said that he felt the County stationary was just fine. It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to forward the project to staff to see if they can come up with a new design based upon the suggestions given. V. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - December 13, 1989 5. Business Staff said that they received correspondence from the Division of Aeronautics asking if this Commission would be interested in forming a committee to help review, revise and update the Airport Land Use Planning Handbook. Staff said that they themselves do not have the time, but thought maybe some of the Commissioners would be interested. Commissioners Walter, Crotts and Alternate Commissioner Gerst agreed to form a Committee to work on the Planning Handbook. Commissioner Lando said that he will make sure the three Commissioners have a copy of the Handbook for their own review and use. Commissioner Lando said that at the last meeting there was a discussion on Assembly Bill 1951. He said that he called the consultant for the airports in Oroville and Chico. He said that the Bill does not affect Chico, but that it affects Oroville, and that is why the application should be submitted on or before January 1, 1990, because of legislation changes. Commissioner Walter briefly reviewed and made comments on the letter from Senator Don Rogers that was enclosed in the packets regarding Chapter 1149 of the Statutes of 1989 which discusses the new regulations that have to be complied with in Capitol Improvement Funding for airports. V. CORRESPONDENCE None. V' VI. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. VII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be January 10, 1990. Th meeting was adjourned at 9:45 a.m. PAT STEVENS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission 9 j me BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT.LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES.- September. 13; 1989 t ' r The meeting of.the Airport Land Use.Coinmission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:02.a.m-..on September'13,•-1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center. Drive, Oroville, California. I PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE �II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Lando, Lambert, Franklin and Vice.Chairman Walter Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Commission has the following corrections and additions: Page 2, .3rd paragraph, add."ALUC""before "Commission"'. r It was moved•by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Lambert to approve the minutes of August 9, 1989, and unanimously carried to approve`the minutes as corrected. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items.to'be discussed. V. BUSINESS .1. Statins Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Commissioner Lando.handed out a cover, -sheet regarding the request for proposal to update the Airport Environs Plan. Commissioner Lando said that the proposals are due October 16, 1989 and that he expects a -significant response based'on the telephone calls he has already received. 'Commissioner. Lando said that if cost isa reasonable figure, the plan will probably.procded right away. Commissioner Lando said that they hoped to have a'Consultant rl BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - September 13, 1989 under contract by mid-November and have a revised plan ready for review by February 1, 1990. COMMISSIONER ROSSAS PRESENT AT THIS TIME vice Chairman Walter said that at the ALUC Meeting held in May, there was a Committee appointed to "assist" Commissioner Lando in reviewing this plan and was questioning if the Committee ever got together. Commissioner Lando said that the Committee included himself and Commissioner Lambert, and never did meet. Commissioner Lando said that he would keep the Commission informed on how the Plan was coming along. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone Staff said that they started to prepare the initial study and ran into some Sections that the ALUC Commission may want to review or revise. Staff said that they are holding off on preparing the initial study until the Sections are reviewed. Staff said that they were going to review the definitions of personal use airports, agricultural use airports or duster strip and agricultural phase airports. Staff said the Code Amendment would add the definitions and require use permits for the base type airports in all agricultural zones. Staff said that they would allow agricultural airports and duster strips in the A-5 through A-160 zones. Staff said that a use permit would be required for personal use airports which would be non - commercially used by an individual owner on his own property in the A-20 through A-160, FR -20 through FR -160 and TM -20 through. TM -160 zones. Staff said they would require a use permit for personal use airports in all zones allowing residential uses. Staff said on Page 6, under Notice of Intent, Sub Paragraph A, regarding height of a structure, would the Commission want it to be within a given radius or for.it to be countywide. Staff said that in Paragraph 2, the concern was 100 to 1, is half the slope of their most restrictive slope in any of the Airport Land Use Plans. Staff said the concern was why be more restrictive, why not just match their own plans and the FAA requirements, which already have the safety factor built in. Commission and staff briefly discussed slope restrictions. 51 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - September 13, 1989 The Commission agreed on the wording of 50 to 1 for the strictive slope area. Staff asked the Commission if they wanted to look at the Overlay Zone at a 100 feet above ground level in a _countywide situation or within 2 or 4 miles within airports. The Commission agreed on countywide and felt it would not hurt. Vice Chairman Walter asked staff when this item would come back before the Commission. Staff said that he would report at the next meeting. vice Chairman Walter requested a status report be placed on the next meetings' agenda. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Commissioner Rossas said that the City of Oroville's consultant has not yet submitted the final plan. He said that the City does have a preliminary plan and to execute the whole plan would be approximately ten million dollars. Commissioner Rossas said that the contracts were open and that the bids came in. He gave a brief update and noted that Robinson Construction would be doing the paving, they are lowest in cost and highest on minority employment. Commissioner Rossas said that the City Council had a meeting regarding the property at the end of the Oroville Airport runway. Commissioner Rossas said that he and the City Public Works Director walked the airport area and said that there would be a lot of earth moving to be done. Vice Chairman Walter asked if the Commission could receive informational briefing on the Master Plan. Commissioner Rossas said yes. Vice Chairman Walter asked if any paper work or General Plan updating needed to be done. Staff said not at this point. Vice Chairman Walter requested that this item be carried forward and placed on the next agenda. e • .BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - September 13, 1989 4. Discussion of Letterhead Design Staff said that ALUC has been using the Planning Department letterhead when they send out correspondence, and suggested that ALUC have their own letterhead. Staff said that they have received a couple of ideas such as the Frisbee Falcon, which was built in the Gridley area and flown in 1921, and. World War II Trainers. The Commission and staff agreed to get some pictures together so they could review them at the next meeting. 5. Business from the Floor There was no business from the floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE Staff said that James Hanna has resigned from the Commission. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES Vice Chairman Walter said that back in May, ALUC was going to send a letter to the Attorney General asking for an interpretation. He said that he has not seen any indication that a further action has taken place. Staff said that nothing has been sent, and that they have talked to County Counsel about the possibility of asking for the Attorney General's opinion. Staff said that the Commission would basically put together a brief report stating the position and asking for an agreement with that position. He said that County Counsel does not have the time to administer this. Commissioner Lambert suggested when there is an opening for this Commission, that the Commission suggest to the City Selection Committee, to nominate an attorney. She said that it would help to have their expertise. Comissioner Rossas said that there are good and bad points to that idea. He said that problems could occur if the attorney was to disagree with County Counsel. Commissioner Lando agreed with Commissioner Rossas. Vice Chairman Walter asked what action has staff taken to put in regulatory form. •'BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND .USE COMMISSION 5 MINUTES - September 13, 1989 Commissioner Lando said that this should be placed on the next' agenda.' vice Chairman suggested that this item be placed on the next agenda. Staff said that staff_might-be putting together an Operations Manual. The.next meeting will be October 11, 1989.. The meeting was adjourned at 9:55 a.m. CARL WALTER, Vice Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /j me as BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - August 9, 1989 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:00 a.m. on August 9, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Staff: III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioners Rossas, Lando, Lambert, Gerst and Chairman Stevens Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes The Commission has the following corrections and additions: Page 2, 1st paragraph, add "Copies of the letter to the City of Chico and other agencies regarding conformity with the Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan were distributed to the Commissioners' for their information". Page 2, 3rd paragraph, delete "while working. on the zoning code".; Page 2, 13th paragraph, add "pertaining to airports" after "zone".; Page 2, 14th paragraph, change "hearing" to having" and add "for overlays" after"sections". It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Rossas to approve the minutes of July 12, 1989, and unanimously carried to approve the minutes as corrected. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Commissioner Lando said that the Chico City Council received the BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - August 9, 1989 letter and were quite concerned and interested and felt that they should hire a consultant to update all projections in the Plan. Commissioner Lando said that the City is contacting their airport consultants as well as the FAA and CalTrans to get names of consultants so that they can start the process. Staff said that if the Chico City Council feels that the environs plan that is currently being used is inadequate or out of date, at the next meeting the Commission could formerly make the finding for the record and require a review by ALUC for any projects that may be submitted. Commissioner Lambert requested that an agenda item be placed on the next agenda regarding making a comparison on the existing environs plan and review on the City's current zoning and general plan for the area. Staff said that they would set up an item so that an action could be taken or it could be continued for the next agenda. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone Commissioner Lambert said that this item was discussed at the Planning Commission per her request. She said that the Planning Commission requested that the Overlay issue be pulled and brought before the Planning Commission. Commissioner Lambert asked for clarification on what has been happening with the airport zones. Staff said that the airport properties for Ranchaero and Paradise have been zoned. He said that staff is still working on an overlay zone or an environs zone that regulates structures, tree heights, roof materials, concentrations of people. Commissioner Rossas asked if this body could be informed of what the thinking is on these projects before they become a full blown issue. Staff said yes. 3. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Commissioner Rossas said that the City only has the preliminary report and has not yet received a final report from Mr. Bramley. He said that Mr. Bramley is waiting for the aerial photos. He also said that the sum total is the same and that the work was certainly adequate. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - August 9, 1989 Chairman Stevens said that she thought the new entrance to the Oroville Airport will be better. 4. Discussion of Letterhead Design It was agreed by both staff and the Commission to discuss possible letterhead designs for their outgoing correspondence. Commissioner Gerst suggested the Frisbee Falcon which was built in Butte County. Commissioner Rossas suggested one of the World war II Trainers. It was decided that the Commission would bring pictures and other ideas to the next meeting.. Commissioner Rossas said that he like the idea of keeping the county logo on the letter head. 5. Business from the Floor There was no business from the floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE None. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be September 13, 1989. The meeting was adjourned at 9:40 a.m. AT STEVENS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /jmc BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - July 12, 1989 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:00 a.m. on July 12, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Gerst, Lambert, Boness, Chairman Stevens Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Commissioner Gerst to approve the minutes of June 14, 1989. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: Gerst, Lambert, Stevens NOES: None ABSENT: Lando, Franklin ABSTAINED: Boness IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Staff said that there was nothing new to report and suggested this item be kept on the agenda. Y 0 • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - July 12, 1989 Copies of the letter to the City of Chico and other agencies regarding conformity with the Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan were distributed to the Commissioners for their information. 2. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone Staff explained that they had not had much time to work on the project but had planned on working on it before this fall. Commissioner Lambert asked where the project stood. Staff said that a draft had been put together and that the environmental work still needed to be finished. Commissioner Lambert asked for clarification on "code amendments." Staff said it would be an overlay zone and that the Board needs to adopt the enabling legislation that allows the Commission to process and overlay zone. Commissioner Lambert asked if at the Planning Commission meeting she could request two parts of the zoning code be pulled separately for review. Staff said yes. Commissioner Lambert asked if she could initiate action by asking the Board to review the enabling legislation separately from the entire Code Revision. Staff said that it could be done at any time and that the Planning Commission needs to request it be done. Commissioner Lambert asked if that would require publication. Staff said not at the Planning Commission level, but at the Board level. Staff suggested having the overlay zone pertaining to airports reviewed by ALUC and have it in its final form and then request the Planning Commission to adopt the zoning. Commissioner Lambert asked staff if having the enabling sections for overlays first would help. Staff disagreed. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES July 12, 1989 Commissioner Lambert was concerned with the amount of time it was taking to complete this project. Commissioner Gerst asked what the difference -was between the overlay zones and the PUD zones. Staff said that a.Planned Unit Development zone is tied to a specific development.plan and that an'overlay zone is able to have height limitations, etc., over a large area, including separate.zones,'uses and ownerships. He said PUD's are specific projects., Chairman Stevens was also concerned about the amount of time it was taking to complete this project. Staff explained the time limits on public initiated projects. Chairman Stevens''requested that this item be kept on the agenda. 3. Status Report - Review of City of,Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs - Commissioner Bones said. that the City's consultant is in the process of recommending several solutions to the situation of, respective runway locations and clear zones and has been through the review process. He said that the consultant was going to recommend that the clear.zones.stay on 'airport or,state property and that they will extend Runway 1-19 to the'southwest. He said that the long range plan was to locate'the terminal and all of the new infrastructure in the open area. Chairman Stevens requested that this item be kept on the agenda. 4. Business from the Floor There was no business from the floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE Staff said that they had received a copy�of Aviation News Monthly and offered to the Commission for their review. Chairman Stevens requested that the Commission receive,copies of ,the monthly magazine if possible.`'. Commissioner Lambert suggested having letterhead paper made.for ALUC. 13 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND.USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - July 12, 1989 It was agreed to have a discussion at the next meeting on letterhead for the Commission. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be August 9, 1989. The meeting was adjourned at 9:53 a.m. � OO)A�x PAT S NS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /j me • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - June 14, 1989 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:05 a.m. on June 14, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Franklin, Walter, Rossas, Lambert, Chairman Stevens Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Rossas, seconded by Commissioner Lambert and unanimously carried to approve the minutes.of May 10, 1989, as corrected. Staff said that they were getting.information.together.to prepare a package for County Counsel regarding the Attorney General's opinion. Staff said that the letter that will be addressed to the City of Chico.is pending on information from County Counsel. Chairman Stevens asked how long this should take. Staff said it should be out before the end of the week. Commissioner Walter asked if staff had talked to County Counsel. Staff said no, not as of this time. Chairman Stevens reminded staff that the letter should also be sent to the City of Chico, Board of Supervisors, City of Oroville and the Town of Paradise. Staff said that they would write the letter and get it to Chairman Stevens for her signature and the would have copies of the letter at the next meeting for the Commission's information. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - June 14, 1989 IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Project Review - Tentative Subdivision Technology Corporation at Eaton Road a the Citv of Chico • p for Sierra Floral Avenue in Staff said that there was a map included in the packets showing the area and the location relative to the traffic corridors. He said that the zoning is in place and that the roads are planned and are in place. He said that most of the property is in the flight corridor. He said that the northerly portion was zoned for light commercial uses and the southerly portion is zoned for duplex residential. Commissioner Walter asked if the area was zoned C-2. Staff said that this was city zoned. 2 Commissioner Lambert -asked if the;Commission was to decide if the parcel could be split into two or if they were to decide on the use that would be appropriate for the land. Staff said that the zoning was in place. Commissioner Walter asked why the Commission was reviewing this project since this Commission is concerned with land uses and not parcel sizes. Staff said that this Commission does review densities to a certain degree, but that this project is a land division and that this one thing this Commission is charged with under the Public Utilities Code. Commissioner Rossas felt that this project should just be confirmed. Commissioner Walter felt it should be noted. Commissioner Lambert asked what difference it made whether it was one or two parcels. Staff said that as far as land use of the property, it would not make much difference. There was a brief discussion. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - June 14, 1989 Commissioner Lambert was in agreement with Commissioner Walter that the Commission note the proposal. Commissioner Walter reviewed and reworded what he thought should be noted: "Since no land use proposal is involved at this time and ALUC has no control over land divisions, it would be inappropriate." Commissioners Rossas and Franklin disagreed strongly. There was a brief discussions on land use and land divisions. It was moved by Commissioner Franklin, seconded by Commissioner Rossas to find this project in conformity with the Plan. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: 'Franklin, Rossas, Stevens NOES: None ABSENT: Lando ABSTAINED: Lambert, Walter Commissioner Rossas said that he felt the reason why the Commission was disagreeing was because they are trying to assert the authority of .this Commission and that they feel frustrated from the fact that it has not been asserted before. Commissioner Rossas said that each city should have 'a representative that attends each meeting. Commissioner Lambert said that this group needs to be pulled together. 2. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Review Commissioner Walter said that he did not know of any action taken yet. Chairman Stevens requested that this item be kept on the agenda. 3. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay r� Zone Staff said that the environmental work had not yet been finished for the Code Amendments. He said that not much would happen at the Board level regarding the Overlay Zones. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - June 14, 1989 - Commissioner Lambert said that it would be great if this Commission could bring the overlay zones in separately through this body. Commissioner Walter asked if there was an action that could be taken by this Commission that would help. Staff said that it had already been started. Staff also said that public projects have certain timelines and that county initiated projects really have no time lines. Commissioner Lambert asked staff if they could ask the Planning Director if there could be a priority placed on this project. 4. Status Report - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Commissioner Rossas said that the report had not came in yet. He said that Mr. Bramley is working on the environmental impact report. He said that there will be a.second hearing when it is completed, hopefully before the next ALUC meeting. Chairman Stevens asked what they were doing with the airport now. Commissioner Rossas said that with the.million dollar grant, they were doing some resurfacing and fencing around the airport. Commissioner Walter clarified that this grant did not include any purchasing of land. Commissioner Rossas agreed. 5. Business from the Floor There was no business from the floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE None. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - June 14, 1989 VMI. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be July 12, 1989.- ,The 989.,The meeting was adjourned ,at 9:50 a.m. PAT STEVENS, Chairman Airport Land`Use Commission /j me 5 • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - May 10, 1989 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to.order at 9:02 a.m. on May 10, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Franklin, Walter, Stevens, Rossas, Lando, Chairman Lambert Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Stevens and unanimously carried to approve the minutes of February 8, 1989, as corrected. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Election of Officers It was reported that a meeting was held after the ALUC meeting of February 8, 1989 by the Airport Managers to reappoint Pat Stevens as an ALUC Commissioner. Staff said that the Vice Chairman automatically moves up to Chairman, and that the new Vice Chairman is selected from among the members that have served a minimum of one year on the Commission. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION. 2 MINUTES.- May 10, 1989 Pat Stevens is the new Chairman. Carl Walter is the new First Vice Chairman. Commissioner Franklin was nominated for Second Vice Chairman. It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Lambert and unanimously carried to elect Commissioner Franklin as Second Vice Chairman. 2. Discussion - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Enforcement and Implementation Commissioner Lambert said that she requested that this item be placed on the agenda because she felt it needed some discussion. It was decided that Item 3 be discussed also at the same time. 3. Discussion - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Commissioner Lambert said that there was a project that was approved in Chico that she felt should have come before ALUC and did not. She said that she wanted to clear the air as to why the project did not come before ALUC and what this Commission needs to do for future projects. She said the project was a Church to be located on the corner of Ceres and Lassen in Chico which is in the approach zone, 6600 feet from the end of the runway. Commissioner Walter reviewed a map, with the Commission, depicting the area. Commissioner Walter said that this project never came before ALUC and felt it should have. Commissioner Walter went over a time line of actions between the County, City of Chico, - and State. Commissioner Lando gave more backup information. Commissioner Lando said that it is time to get serious about the Airport Environs Plan for Chico and find out who is correct, have someone else look at projects and what the protected area ought to be. He said that the City does have the clear zone, a mile at the end of the runway. Commissioner Lando handed out maps showing the area of the existing zoning plan for Foothill Park, one showing details regarding some specific projects, and one showing the compatible land use zones relative to the airport to the Commission. Commissioner Lambert asked if the process would have been different if it would have came before ALUC. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - May 10, 1989 Commissioner Lando said yes. Staff said that the requirements for review by ALUC are for General Plan Amendments, Rezones, changes in building standards, etc. Staff said that normally Use Permits and Variances conform to the zoning and General Plan and would not come before ALUC. Staff said that if the zoning and general plan are in place and are adequate that anything that happens underneath them would be in conformance with the plan. Staff said that both the City and County review periods are short. The timing was such that there was no way they could get into an ALUC hearing and have time to get it back to the City for their Planning Commission hearing. Staff comments to the city recommended denial of the church use permit. Commissioner Walter said that since the State denied the Church project, it should have triggered some kind of holding action until it had been thoroughly reviewed. Staff said that this Commission can only make recommendations on use permits and variances. Staff also said that under the State law, it is not mandatory for use permits and variances be forwarded to ALUC. Commissioner Franklin said that the Commission needs to impose something that would tie down the general plans and zoning. Staff said they analyze projects in terms of the adopted plan, if the plan calls for Airport Land Use Commission input, then it is taken to the Commission, if it is very clear that it is allowed or not allowed, staff can respond. Commissioner Lando suggested that if there is a doubt that a project is not consistent, or that there may be a problem, the particular corresponding agencies should request that the item be denied or continued and be brought to ALUC. He said if the project is consistent there should not be a problem. Commissioner Walter said that it was his impression that whenever the Airport Environs Plan was overridden by the City or a municipality, they had the authority to do it, but that they had to make an overriding finding, and then they were responsible legally for any damages that might occur at any later time. Staff said that if this Commission finds that the City does not revise the general plan or specific plan or overrule the Commission by a two-thirds vote of its government body after making specific findings., etc., the Commission may require that the City submit all subsequent actions, regulations and permits to the Commission for review. • • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - May 10, 1989 Commissioner Lando said that he thought it would be appropriate for ALUC to send a letter to the City indicating that they are quite concerned, based on the existing approved Environs Plan, that there is an inconsistency. Fred Stewart, Department of Transportation, asked if there was an adopted Chico Land Use Plan adopted by ALUC. Staff said the predecessor to this body was the County Planning Commission acting as the Airport Land Use Commission. Mr. Stewart told the Commission that they were not the only body that was having these dilemmas. He said that the City has opted not to take action to make it's General Plan consistent with the Airport Land Use Plan. Mr. Stewart asked if the City of Chico submitted their General Plan to ALUC for determination of whether it is consistent with the Chico Airport Land Use Plan. Staff said the Specific Plan was adopted for this area shortly after this plan was adopted, noting some inconsistencies. Commissioner Lando asked if ALUC then found the plan compatible and if the new ALUC body does not. Mr. Stewart said that things change over time and would not expect that a body acting in 1979 would bind any subsequent thought later on. He said that if this body reviewed the Plan and had sufficient rationale to support the decision, it could be very easily said that the Commission does not find it consistent with the CLUP. He said that there would be no reason why an amendment to the CLUP could not be done. Commissioner Franklin said that if the Commission does find that there should be a change, unless the City or County amend their zoning to match the Commissions' change, requests for comments would still not come before ALUC, and the old zoning would still be in effect. Mr. Stewart said that they would have to do so within a time frame, and if they fail to do so, they must send all zoning actions to ALUC for their action before they can approve it. He said that they can ignore you, but that it would probably end up in court. Staff said that if the Commission was to find that their plans were not consistent, that 60 day and 180 day time limits could not possibly be met and still conform to the provisions or the BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 5 MINUTES - May 10, 1989 Government Code or-CEQA. :f Commissioner Lando said that he was skeptical about the ability to withdraw the approval after it has 'been there. He'said that the alternate approach would be .to adopt a new plan. Commissioner Rossas said that a statement regarding this discussion•be submitted'to the City in case of a plane going through the church while it was being occupied. He felt that it: should be in writing and transferred to the City of Chico with a copy, so if something happens, and it goes into court, and there is litigation, the City of Chico could not be blamed. COMMISSIONER LANDO ABSENT AT THIS TIME Staff said that the County did respond with a recommendation for denial. Commissioner Walter suggested that staff be directed to write a strong letter to'the City of Chico stating that the Airport Land Use Commission feels that they should have been consulted and call attention to the fact that the State denied the project and that ALUC concurs with the'State. � y . Commissioner Lambert suggested sending:a copy of this letter to the Board of Supervisors. 4 Chairman Stevens'asked Mr. Stewart and Mr. Smith, both, representatives from CalTrans, if they,had any suggestions or input on the letter to be addressed to,the City of Chico.' Mr. Stewart agreed that if.this body was'not on record, that they certainly need to be., He said that writing to -the City of Chico' and sending a copy to the Board of Supervisors seems to be,a good idea. ° There was a brief discussion on the location of the church and it was agreed that it was not in a good location. Commissioner Walter asked if the proposed school was built in the vicinity.of the project area. Commissioner Franklin said it had not`been built yet. Regaring the school,site that was approved, Carl'Smith,. Department of Transportation, said that there had been initially five sites considered in 1986 that the Department of Transportation evaluated. He said that of the five sites that were evaluated, two were acceptable with•:reservations. He said that the one that was selected was the'one that was most unlikely' BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 6 MINUTES - May 10, 1989 to be a suitable place for a school. There was a brief discussion on the noise contours. Mr. Smith also said that there is a proposed high density housing tract which will be a bad situation because of there being a high concentration of people. Commissioner Walter asked that in view of the fact that the State recommendation has been overturned by the City, what action if any does the State contemplate now? Mr. Stewart said that there might be State action by the Attorney General, because of the process being abused by both the city and county not following the legislative prescribed procedure for things, i.e., reviewing its general plan to make it consistent with the CLUP. Mr. Stewart said that if ALUC wishes to enforce its powers and duties as prescribed by the legislature, they could do it in a number of ways City and County and/or within the County, sometimes the Attorney General will take a position on issues broader than just a single County issue. Staff said that maybe they need to ask their County Counsel as to whether a zone conforms to the plan even if that zone allowed uses through the use permit process that might not conform. Chairman Stevens asked if this Commission had any tabling powers; for example, when the request came, could staff have referred it back and say that it will have to go before ALUC. It was moved by Commissioner Franklin, seconded by Commissioner Walter To contact County Counsel to ask for the Attorney General's opinion on compatibility of zones that contain use permit items that would not conform to the Airport Land Use Plans and also to send copies of correspondence to California Aviation and the Division of Aeronautics. The motion carried as follows: AYES: Franklin, Walter, Rossas, Lambert, Stevens NOES: No one ABSENT: Lando ABSTAINED: No one Staff said that they could have done that, but was not sure if the City would have paid any attention. Staff asked what kind of authority does CalTrans have from a safety standpoint in terms of the size of'the aircraft using an BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND.USE COMMISSION 7 MINUTES:- May 10; 1989 airport. Staff asked if it was going to.be self limiting. Mr. Smith said that the State basically does not restrict an airport use on the type of aircraft that -land and takeoff from that airport. Mr. Smith said that when the FAA has money involved in an airport, they become more aggressive with respect on how they comment. 4. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone Staff said that the airport zones for both Paradise and Ranchaero are adopted and in place. Staff'said the code amendments, a set of requirements, and an overlay zoning regulating height still have to be prepared. Staff said there was nothing else new to report:' 5. Status Conform 4 rt - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Oroville Munci al Airport Environs Staff said that they have been working'with Wally Boness from the City of Oroville. Commissioner Rossas said that Mr. Bramley, City of Oroville's consultant, is preparing the Oroville'Airport Master Plan. Commissioner Rossas said that Mr. Bramley gave a verbal preliminary report which looks extremely good. Mr. Bramley has all of the data'and facts and all that has to be done is write the final report. Commissioner Rossas said that hopefully when ALUC meets again, he will be able to}have the final report. Commissioner Rossas said that the thresholds have been moved and that the expansion of the airport will be to the south. Commissioner Rossas said that the City received a grant for one million dollars which.will repaint the runways, buy taxi lights and fence the airport. Commissioner Walter said he did not see•any of the money for the purchase of the strip of land toward the afterbay. Commissioner Rossas said that was another project with other funds. Commissioner Rossas said that in Mr. Bramley's report, he. gradually wants to move all of the airport facilities into the triangle in between the runways and lengthen runway 01-19.- i a i BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION,,8" MINUTES - May 10, 1989 d Chairman Stevens asked if the entrance would be on Larkin Road since the new plan is to shift the airport facilities to the south. Commissioner Rossas was not sure. Mr. Smith said that from a safety point of view, the entrance should be moved because'it is now encroaching into the runway. COMMISSIONER FRANKLIN ABSENT AT THIS TIME Commissioner Walter said he reviewed the Aviation Element of the Regional Transportation Plan 1988 and"'had noticed that the Oroville Airport Administrative and Operative expenses were $65,500.00. He said that Chico only spent $46,245.00 on Administrative and Operatives expenses. Commissioner Walter mentioned that the beacon out at the Oroville Airport has been operating on a test basis for nearly"one year and is going great. He said it is reliable, has good range and is a good safety factor. 6. Business from the Floor Commissioner Walter recommended that staff be directed to consult the Chairman each time on whether a meeting should be held and what the agenda of the meeting should be. Chairman Stevens requested that the Oroville Environs Report, - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan and the Overlay -Zones be kept on the agenda. The Commission appointed Commissioner's Lando, Franklin and.Walter to work on a committee for the review?of the Chico Airport Environs Plan. Commissioner Walter wanted clarification on responsibilities and roles of the Commission regarding people who are involved with items that effect aviation and airports. He asked what documents, policies, and ordinances is the Commission to participate in and either review or initiate. He asked how the documents are processed and in what sequence, by whom and when. He said flow charts would show how these things get done and where they sit, -'so -they don't get overlooked. Mr. Stewart said that their letter dated April 4, 1989 only took a position of a recommendation on the school site. He said that • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 9 MINUTES - May 10, 1989 their action is simply advisory. VI: CORRESPONDENCE None. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be June.14, 1989. The meeting was adjourned at 11:05 a.m. PAT STEVENS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /j me BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - February 8, 1989 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:00 a.m. on February 8, 1989, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Franklin, Walter, Stevens, Lando, Chairman Lambert Staff: III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to'approve the minutes of October 12, 1988 as corrected. It was moved by Commissioner Stevens, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to approve the minutes of the November 9, 1988 meeting as written. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Air -port Zone, Code.Amendments, and Overlay Zone. Staff said that the airport zone would be presented to the Planning Commission on February 9, 1989. Staff said that there BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - February 8, 1989 were some changes which shifted the use permit requirement for a caretakers residence over to the allowed use section. Staff said that scheduled air carriers and uses involving the storage of fuel were moved to the use permits section. Staff said the intent of the ordinance was not changed, the same types of applications are included. Chairman Lambert said one of the main concerns of the residents were the traffic and speed of traffic. Staff said that both the Code Amendment and Overlay zone have not had any previous environmental work done. Staff said that they were in the process of preparing the environmental documents. Chairman Lambert asked for clarification on the Code Amendments. Staff said that Code Amendments would add some definitions into the overall zoning code that would define ag-airport, ag-base airport, private airports and require use permits for the private airports and the ag-base airport. The Overlay zone would be the height limits, noise, light and glare standards around the airport. Chairman Lambert asked about BCAG's Transportation Element. Staff said that the Element had been finished. Commission and staff briefly discussed the requirements of environmental documents. Commissioner Walter asked who in staff was working on this project. Staff said that Dave Hironimus was the primary planner. Staff said that they would bring this item back when there was something new to report. 2. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. Staff said that there was nothing new to report. Chairman Lambert asked if BCAG was going to do some studies. Staff said that it was a possibility but that it was not a formal action. This item was carried forward. f BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - February 8, 1989 3. Discussion - Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Staff said that there was nothing new to report. This item was carried forward. 4. Report - Expiration of Commissioner Stevens' Term on May 1, 1989. (Appointed by the Airport Manager's Association). Chairman Lambert said that a group of the airport managers need to get together and reappoint Commissioner Stevens or a replacement. Since there was a quorum of airport managers present, a short meeting was scheduled after this meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission. 5. Business From The Floor Commissioner Walter said that he had reviewed some information from the California Aviation Council which is a private organization of all California aviation activities. Commissioner Walters said he noticed that they had airport representatives at all major airports. He asked if Butte County knew that they were not listed. Commissioner Stevens said that you have to pay to get into the organization. She*said that you can join as a group or individually. Chairman Lambert asked what these groups do. Commissioner Walters said that they lobby. There was a brief discussion. Wendell Jones said he belonged to the E.A.A., a group which is active and meets monthly. He said this organization sent letters to the F.A.A. and Congressman regarding the zoning for some 246 airports. He said that the group is trying to get them to modify this. Mr. Jones said that if this Commission contacts Jim Culliton, President of the E.A.A., maybe they could do something about this. I S BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION. 4 MINUTES - February 8, 1989 VI. CORRESPONDENCE Staff said that they had received the Inventory Element from the California Aviation Systems Plan which has some good information and is available at.the Planning Office. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be March 8, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 9:28 a.m. wNA.LAMBERT, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /j me a BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE -COMMISSION MINUTES - November 9, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called. to order at 9:05 a.m. on November 9, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center' Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL. Present: Commissioners Franklin, Boness, Stevens, Chairman Lambert Staff:Dave Hronimus, Jill Cervantes Brent. Moore. III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Chairman Lambert corrected the motion on Page 6, Paragraph 3 to read as follows: "It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to move for approval of the cover page of said proposed code amendments with 3a as proposed, delete 3b, move for approval as amended of the proposed airport zone and move for conceptual approval of the third document which is Airport Overlay zone." The approval of the minutes for the October 12, 19.88 meeting was continued.to the December 14, 1988 meeting. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT MINUTES - November*9, LAND USE COMMISSION 1988 • 1. Status Report - Airport Zone, Code Amendments, and Overlay Zone. Staff said that the Planning Commission initiated the project to adopt code amendments. Staff also explained the comment procedure and environmental review process and said the project was progressing. 2 Chairman Lambert asked for this item to be carried forward to the December.agenda. 2. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review. Staff said a committee had not been formed and that there was nothing new to report. 3. Discussion - 1988 Aviation Element Update, Supplement to the 1986 Butte County Regional Transportation Plan. Mr. Moore explained briefly the Regional Transportation Plan for Butte County which is prepared by the Butte County Association 'of Governments. He said that the Butte County Association of Governments was formed to carry out regional type projects and projects that transcend jurisdictional boundaries. Mr. Moore said that staff is in the process of revising the document by showing the need for airports and addressing issues such as funding, financing and inventory in our county airports. Mr. Moore said he would be mailing out the draft to the Commission, interested agencies and to people who are in the tourism industry, airport and pilot operators, people who work in major industries along flight lines and people who work for air carriers, and air cargo transportation companies. He said a committee meeting would be scheduled to prepare the final draft. He also said when the final draft was completed, it would then be ready to go before the Butte County Association of Governments. There was a small.discussion on transportation in and around airports in Butte County. Mr. Moore suggested to the Commission that as the Airport Land Use Commission they request the Butte County Association of Governments conduct the necessary planning studies to develop an Airport Master Plan for Chico Municipal due to its regional BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - November 9, 1988 significance and ask the Butte County Association of Governments to look for other sources of funding for the Airport Master Plan. Chairman Lambert asked.that this item be continued to the December meeting. 4. Business From The Floor. There was no business from the Floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE There was no correspondence. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF. AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES None.. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be December 14, 1988. The meet ing- was adj ourned' at 9:41 a.m. N A LAMBERT, Chairman A'rport Land Use Commission. /j me 0 REVISED MINUTES BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - October 12, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:00 a.m. on October 12, 1-988, in the Board.of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Franklin, Lando, Gerst, Rossas, Chairman Lambert Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes Brent Moore Also Present: Wally Boness, City of Oroville III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner. Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin to approve the minutes of August 10, 1988. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: Franklin, Lando, Gerst, Lambert NOES: None ABSENT: Stevens, Walter ABSTAINED: Rossas IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. Staff welcomed Jim Rossas, a new Commissioner selected by the City Selection. Committee. V. BUSINESS .BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - October 12, 1988 1. AZ Code Amendment, including private, commercial and ag (base) airports Staff said that they are in the process implementing policies and plans for the AZ code amendment. Staff discussed the following zones: 1. Specific zone for airport property. 2. Overlay zone that governs height limits and other airport/aircraft hazards around airports. 3. Code amendment that would define the requirements of use permits, airports, ag-strips, agricultural base airports, and private strips. Staff reviewed the following code amendments: 1. :Personal use airport. 2. Agricultural airport. 3. Agricultural Base airport. Chairman�Lambert had reservations about the occasional invited guest using the personal use airport. She questioned how the definition could be enforced. Staff stated that.the language was listed from both State and Federal definitions. Chairman Lambert asked if the language should be in the code. Staff said yes. Commissioners Lando and Franklin said that they shared'the same concern as Chairman Lambert. Commissioner Lando and Chairman Lambert said that,for personal use airports, use permits should be required in all zones. Commissioner Lando asked what the definition was for the R -C zone. Staff said that it is a Resource Conservation zone, which is normally applied to areas where there is a sensitive resource, rare or endangered species or something that should not let the area be developed. Commissioner Lando suggested additional language stating BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - October 12, 1988 "Excepting the R -C zones where such an airport is not allowed." Commissioner Lando asked what the purpose was distinguishing between agricultural airports vs. agricultural base airport. Staff stated that the agricultural airport would be for crop duster use with no permanent facilities, etc. An agricultural base airport would be a permanent on-site maintenance, fuel storage, etc. on base airport. He said that the agricultural airport would be permitted in ag zones. Commissioner Lando questioned the County's Ordinance being clear unless a use is specifically permitted, it is prohibited. Staff stated yes. 3 Staff pointed out that other large acreage zonings such as F -R and TM allow aircraft landing facilities in their language already. He said that the TPZ zone allows uses compatible with logging operations such as helicopter decks for logging purposes. Chairman Lambert questioned why an A-20 through A-1'60 zone is needed when applying for a personal use permit. Chairman Lambert questioned if someone with a large acreage parcel wanted to apply for an air strip/personal air strip and was not in an A. TM or FR zone, would a use permit not be required? Staff stated that they would probably have to rezone to another zone because the zones do not specifically permit that. Staff discussed briefly the A -Z zones for specific properties for commercial style of public access airports and overlay zones.. Chairman Lando said that the zoning on ground seems to be straight forward. He asked if it would be appropriate to tie into the adopted plans in terms of compatibility under the Development Standards. Mr. Moore, Planning Staff, asked if they should state that development must be geared to adopted master plans for airport. Mr. Moore said that there seems to be several plans for each airport: Butte County General Plan, Airport Environs Plan and a Chico Area Land Use Plan. He asked if this was to be referred to the Airport Master Plans that have been developed for Airport Land Use Plans for each airport._ • • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - October 12, 1988 Commissioner Lando agreed. Mr. Moore stated that when a prezone is requested, adopted plans should be consistent with the State Law and Airport Land Use Plans be consistent to the County's General.Plans. Commissioner Lando stated that it should be stated for a couple reasons, it is typically not adopted as part of the General Plan and not referenced unless the County has changed its General Plan, and when someone is referencing to this document they should know what the constraints are. Mr. Moore suggested adding wording such as "Proposed sites for airport zoning where no airport is in existence shall demonstrate that it can meet all permitting requirements of the California Department of Transportation, Division of Aeronautics, and is compatible and consistent with the Butte County Airport Land Use Plans in accordance to Government Code Section 65000" which states that the general plan and zoning have to be consistent. He said that they would reference this to the State Law. Chairman Lambert asked about'fuel farms being underground storage or big tanks. Mr. Moore stated that it could be either. He said that a lot of airports have large fuel farms so that they can make sure they can service the aircrafts that are coming in and out. He said that it was clarified under Item No. 1 under the first section. Chairman Lambert questioned use permits being required because it deals with groups of people and commercial uses. Mr. Moore stated that it was not a direct application of the airport. He said it may lend itself to an airport, but the primary purpose of an airport is the aviation operation. Commissioner Gerst questioned Item No. 1 under the Development Standards. Mr. Moore said that it was not discussing airport operations, but that it was discussing the land uses around the airport. Mr. Moore said that the definition of nuisance in the Ordinance would help set parameters of how much noise and vibrations and would help clarify overall. Staff stated that the definition of nuisance is already in the County Code. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - October 12, 1988 Mr. Moore stated that the draft Ordinance is in regards to an overlay zone which controls land uses surrounding airports. Commissioner Lando asked where this Ordinance came from. Mr. Moore said that it was a compilation of several proposals. Commissioner Lando questioned if the Ordinance had been reviewed by the State. 5 Mr. Moore said that it had been mailed for review to the Division of Aeronautics, California Commission of Airports and Aviation, and the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA). Commissioner Lando asked how this compared to the existing section that is in the Code. Mr. Moore said that there is no overlay zone. Chairman Lambert stated that there was not an overlay zone and that it is proposed in the code amendment but has not yet been adopted. Staff stated that the County has a height limit zone which has not been enforced. Chairman Lambert asked if any comments on the Ordinance had came back from the State. Mr. Moore said that the State was pleased with it. Commissioner Franklin said the rezone should be encouraged. Chairman Lambert stated that this item could go forward to the Planning Commission on October 20, 1988 to initiate the zoning code amendment. Mr. Moore said that the Commission needs to make a motion authorizing the Chairman to send a letter to the Butte County Planning Commission to initiate code amendment actions and recommend that the following zones be proposed and following amendments be adopted. Commissioner Lando said that he had no problems with the intent but that he did have problems with the content. Commissioner Lando said that staff should be aware that the, Ordinance itself seems to have a filing fee in it. He said that this makes it very difficult to change filing fees if the need to ever update them or produce them. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 6 MINUTES - October 12, 1988 Commissioner Lando said that the Ordinance needed to be in proper format. He said that he had another concern with the height restriction of 100 feet which should be related to the transition zone or some type of meaningful relationship to the airport. Mr. Moore said that in the Ordinance now, if one was going to build or grow something within the overlay zone that is 100 feet or taller, one would have to file a notice of intent. He said that when the notice of intent is filed, it would be reviewed. He said that the process is similar to the general plan conformance report process and is strictly a staff review process. It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to move for approval of the cover page of said proposed code amendments with 3a as proposed, delete 3b, move for approval as'amended of the proposed airport zone and move for conceptual approval of the third document which is Airport Overlay zone. Chairman Lambert asked if this item would be heard at the Planning Commission on October 20, 1988. Mr. Moore said that this item would be placed on the Agenda as a miscellaneous item, and that the Planning Commission would need to make a motion initiating the project. Commissioner Gerst questioned if the terminology could be clarified under the non -conforming uses under definitions. Mr. Moore said that it would be clarified. RAF Review of Rezone from SR -3 (Suburban -Residential parcels) to PUD (Planning Unit Development) near Municipal Airport - Thomas Reed 3 acre hico Staff briefly discussed the location of the rezone for Thomas Reed. _ Commissioner Lando.said that he did not have a problem with the project as long as the uses are compatible. Chairman Lambert questioned what kind of application this was. Staff said that the project intends to be general light industrial uses to be located inside buildings. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT MINUTES - October 12, LAND USE COMMISSION 1988 • It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to find this project compatible with the Airport Environs Plan as long as it is limited to light industrial uses within buildings 7 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Staff reported that there had not been much progress. 4. Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Staff said that the City has been working on their plan. Wally Boness, City of Oroville, said that the City Selection Committee has selected a consultant and that FAA is in the process of reviewing the proposed agreement. He said as soon as agreement is reviewed and Public Works received the agreement, it will then be taken to Council with the recommendation. He said hopefully this will happen next month. He said after this, it would be about a 13 -month work plan with the consultant to come up with the new master plan. He also said he would keep the Commission informed. Chairman Lambert requested that this item be brought back for the January 1989 agenda. 5. Review of Pre -Application for Federal Assistance for Chico Municipal Airport Staff said that this information only item and does not require and action to take place. Commissioner Lando explained that the Airport Improvement Program, City of Chico's entitlement airport. He said that the program has worked out in conjunction with FAA and that they actually tell the City of Chico they want to fund and what is fundable. He said that they go back and.forth with the project lists in combination with the City requests and their requests which have to be approved and eligible. The Commission briefly discussed the funding between State and City. 6. Business From The Floor BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 8 MINUTES - October 12, 1988 There was no business from the Floor.. VI. CORRESPONDENCE COMMISSIONER LANDO ABSENT AT THIS TIME Staff.stated that they had received a communication from the Department of Transportation, Division of Aeronautics, regarding Assembly Bill 1398, a new Airport Land Use Plan being eligible for state funds for preparation of comprehensive plans. There was a brief discussion on the Bill. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be November 9, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 10:10 a..m.. NA LAMBERT, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /j me BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES -,August 10, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:05 a.m. on August 10, 1988, in the Personnel Training Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE i II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Boness, Walter, Stevens, Chairman Lambert. Staff: Dave-Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Boness, seconded by Commissioner Stevens to approve the minutes of July 13, 1988, with the following clarification. Commissioner Stevens clarified her presence in the first hearing. on page two. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS k 1. Review of Tentative Parcel Map For Ron Ca orale, AP#042-15-0-005,019, Ranchaero Airport Zoning This project was not noticed correctly for the meeting of July 13, 1988, therefore it was noticed again for this meeting for the Commission to make proper findings and to make a motion of recommendation. Chairman Lambert noted that the applicant nor the representative were present. . Chairman Lambert opened the hearing to the public. There was no one to speak. J • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - August 10, 1988 Chairman Lambert closed the hearing to the public. Chairman Lambert said she was in support of the project because the general plan designation and zoning is in place and that this project is one of the last to be developed. Staff said that a Planning Director's Report has been prepared for the Advisory Agency hearing of August 15, 1988, and that Condition No. 4 read "Grant an avigation easement to the operators of the Ranchaero Airport to provide notice for future owners that they may be subject to noise, dust and vibration from airport operations.." Commissioner Boness asked about the project being subject to Environmental Review and if it was necessary to put it in the motion. Staff said that the Environmental -Review has been- completed on the project, and that the Commission needs to make a recommendation as to approval or denial of the project for the. Advisory Agency so that they.can consider it when they hear it at their meeting of August 15, 1988. It was moved by-Commissioner'.Boness,.�.seconded--by Commissioner Walter and carried to recommend approval of the Subdivision subject to an A_vigation Easement and subject to the Environmental Review and any other means '-,there-might be.to assist in mitigating the impact of the project on the airport. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES:- Boness, Walter, Lambert NOES: Stevens ABSENT: Lando, Franklin, Hanna ABSTAINED: None 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport & Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning Staff said that they needed to get the Airport Zone squared away before they could zone the Airport with it. Staff also said that they are working on a rezone in the south Paradise area and that without the A -Z. zone being ready, staff recommendations are to take it the Planning Commission with two options: 1. Zone the airport the same zoning that is in the surrounding area; or BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - August 10, 1988 2. Leave the zoning "U". Under the "U" zoning an airport is an allowed use with a Use Permit. It was agreed to carry this item forward. 3. AZ Code Amendment, 'including private,'commercial and ag. (base) airports. Staff reported that there had not been much progress. Commissioner Walter asked when the Committee could get together and review their drafts. Staff said that they would like to go through and review -the zones before the Committee meets. Chairman Lambert asked if staff could prepare a definition for the Commission as to what "Ag -Base Airport" means. It was agreed to carry this item forward. 4. Business from the Floor There was no bus.iness .fr-:om ,the .Floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE Staff said they received a letter from Commissioner Dennis Harvey stating his resignation is effective as of November 1988. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES Chairman Lambert asked if staff could supply the Commission with copies of avigation easement document. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The.next meeting will be September 14, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at,9:15 a.m. N NA LAMBERT, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission /jmc BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - July 13, 1988 The.meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:05,a.m. on July 13, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Boness, Lando, Gerst, Chairman Lambert Also Present: Henry Roberson, Manager'of Ranchaero Airport, Jim Stevens, NorthStar Engineering Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Boness to approve the minutes of April 13, 1988. The motion carried by the.following vote: AYES: Boness, Lando, Lambert NOES: None ABSENT: Franklin and Stevens ABSTAINED: Gerst APPROVAL OF JUNE 8, 1988 -MINUTES Chairman Lambert pointed out that after the vote for Chairman, she should be referred to as "Chairman Lambert" instead of "vice Chairman Lambert". Commissioner Gerst suggested that minut.es.should have more coverage of the meetings. It was moved by Commissioner Boness,'seconded by Commissioner Lando, and unanimously -carried to approve the minutes as corrected'. COMMISSIONER FRANKLIN PRESENT AT THIS TIME BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 2 MINUTES - July 13, 1988 IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. COMMISSIONER STEVENS PRESENT AT THIS TIME V. BUSINESS 1. Election of Second Vice Chairman for 1988-89 Commissioner Walter was nominated for Second Vice Chairman by Commissioner Gerst, seconded by Commissioner Lando and carried by the following vote: AYES: • Boness, Lando, Franklin, Stevens, Lambert NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAINED: None la Review of Tentative Parcel Map For Ron Caporale, AP#042-15-0-005,019, Ranchaero Airport Zoning Chairman.Lambert'noted that the applicant nor the representative were present at the last hearing held for this project held on June 8, 1988. Staff said that the Commission needed to make a recommendation to the Advisory Agency. Staff said that the Commission had forwarded a finding that the project might have a significant impact on the air transportation in the area. Staff also said that a statement had been made that similar projects had been successfully mitigated by granting an avigation easement'to the airport owner and that this type of mitigation measure would be adequate in this case. Commissioner'Lando asked in the applicant was willing to put an avigation easement on the property. Jim Stevens, NorthStar Engineering, representing Ron Caporale, said that Mr. Caporale has agreed to an avigation easement. Commissioner Franklin said that as long as there is an avigation easement, he sees no.problem. Commissioner Lando agreed with Commissioner Franklin. r l: Sr. 0 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 3 MINUTES - July 13, 1988 Commissioner Lando agreed with Commissioner Franklin. Chairman Lambert closed the hearing to the public. Commissioner Stevens said she had a negative note for this project. It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded -by Commissioner Boness and carried to recommend approval of the Subdivision subject to an Avigation Easement and subject to the Environmental Review and any other means there might be to assist in mitigating the impact of the airport on the project. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: Boness, Lando,, Franklin, Lambert NOES: Gerst and Stevens ABSENT: None ABSTAINED: None 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning Staff reported that there had not been much progress on putting the drafts together for both the Paradise and Ranchaero Airport zonings. Staff recommended that this item be carried forward on the agenda. 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review Staff said that they had not had a chance to meet with Commissioner Lando to discuss the Chico Municipal Airport. Commissioner Lando said that he was -interested in reviewing the project, but that it was not a high priority project. Staff recommended that.this item be removed from the agenda and be brought back in three months. 4. Review of City of Oroville General P1an,Conformity - Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Staff said that they need to contact the City of Oroville to get h BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 4 MINUTES - July 13, 1988 details on where the new thresholds are and what the zoning and general plan looks like around the airport so that they can make a finding. Commissioner Boness said that there had not been to much progress, but that the City had been funded to prepare a new master plan for the airport. Staff recommended that this item be removed from the agenda and be brought back in three months. S. AZ Code Amendment Chairman Lambert said that there was nothing new to report. 6. Business from the Floor There was no business from the Floor. VI. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES Staff said that they had received a referral from Yuba County - stating that they were in the process of adopting a General Plan Amendment and Ordinance for,implementation of the Beale Air Force Base Airport.Land Use Plan. Staff said that this does affect Butte County somewhat in that some of their noise contours comes up over the south County boundary in the Honcut area. Staff said that they would carry the information forward onto the noise element and mapping. VII. CORRESPONDENCES Brent Moore, Associate Planner, said that he had recently talked to Senator Don Rogers and.that he had asked if this Commission could put a letter together and send it to Assemblyman John Vacconcellos, Chair of Assembly Ways & Means supporting Senate Bill 263. Mr. Moore said that Senate.Bill 263 has been amended. Mr. Moore reported Senate Bill 263 amendment has changed the existing law for ALUC's. ALUC's will be the primary agency to deal with noise problems at airports under Senate Bill 263. He said that another way the Bill has changed is that the large sums of money will not be appropriated this fiscal year. He said that this year they would appropriate only enough money to start the procedural r • BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - July.13, 1988 mechanism rolling and in subsequent years, the funding for airport capital improvements would.come. Mr. Moore read the letter that staff had previously prepared and recommended this Commission support Senate Bill 263 and sign the letter. 5 Commissioner Lando said that he was after local control. He said that he felt that funding should be for improvements and not for planning. He said that he feels this Commission should not be in a position to have to tell the County or Cities that they have to make major expenditures of funds or effect the operation of their airport because of noise problems. Mr. Moore said that the Bill will fund ALUC's directly and that ALUC's will then be solely responsible to abate noise problems at airports. It was moved by Commissioner Lando, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to be in support .of letter being sent in support of the Rogers Bill, Senate Bill 263. Commissioner Stevens asked why it was determined this year to not fund all the money, but appropriate a portion of it, and where is the rest going? l Mr. Moore said the remainder of the money is put back into the general fund. He said the money from jet fuel taxes are normally put into this fund. He said that this year the jet fuel taxes will add close to one hundred million to the State's general fund. He said from that one hundred million, the bill would appropriate a little over one million to begin the program. He said that once the program begins, there will be a maximum of 2 percent of the funding that will go to Planning purposes and preparing the Regional Aviation System Plan, California Aviation System Plan and the Capitol Improvement Programs for all airports in the state. He said that 98 percent of the funding has to go directly to improvement of airports. Commissioner Stevens asked if this would be a one-time project where they are not going to allocate all funds. Mr. Moore said yes. Commissioner Franklin asked if they were going to allow funding to public use - privately owned airports. Mr. Moore said he was not sure. He said that another private airport was going under and decided to contract with their County, the'County then got funding to keep the airport in BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION 6 MINUTES - July 13, 1988 business'. Mr. Moore said that FAA is making,an agreement to fund certain portions of Planning that will have to take place to implement the Bill, if the Bill passes, there will be an opportunity to go after FAA funding. COMMISSIONER LANDO ABSENT AT THIS TIME Chairman Lambert asked if each County had an Airport*Land Use Commission. Mr. Moore said that not every County had one, but that every County that has a scheduled airline is required by law to have one or a body that acts as one. Chairman Lambert reread the motion for clarification. J Staff said that James Hanna has been named by the City Selection Committee to replace Commissioner Dave Stephens position. Staff also said that Commissioner Dennis Harvey will be resigning as of November, and in the mean time Commissioner Wally Boness will be serving an his alternate. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be August 10, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 9:50 a.m. N A LAMB RT, Chairman irport Land Use.Commission /j me BUTTE COUNTY�AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION { MINUTES - June,8, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to 'order at 9:15 a.m. on June, 8, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive; Oroville, California. r I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL'CALL• Present: Commissioners Stevens, Boness, Gerst, Vice Chairman.Lambert Also Present: Henry,Roberson, Manager of Ranchaero Airport Staff: Dave'Hironimus, Jill Cervantes III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the April 13, 1988 'minutes were continued to the meeting of July 13, 1988. - IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Election of Chairman and Vice -Chairman for 1988-89 There was a brief discussion on the requirements of the ByLaws. Commissioner Lambert was nominated for Chairman by Commissioner Boness, seconded by Commissioner' Stevens and carried by 'the following vote: 1 AYES: Commissioners Boness, Stevens and Gerst NOES: No one ABSENT: Commissioners Franklin, Stephens and Chairman Lando ABSTAINED:. Vice Chairman Lambert BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - June 8, 1988 Commissioner Stevens was nominated, for First Vice Chairman by Commissioner Gerst, seconded by Commissioner Boness and carried by the following vote: AYES: Commissioner Boness, Gerst and Chairman Lambert NOES: No one ABSENT: Commissioners Franklin, Stephens and Chairman Lando ABSTAINED: Commissioner Stevens It was moved- by Commissioner Gerst, seconded by Commissioner Stevens and unanimously carried to elect the Second Vice Chairman at the July 13, 1988 meeting. 2. Review of Tentative Parcel.Map For - Ron Caporale, AP#042-15-0-005,019, Ranchaero Approach Zone It was noted that the applicant nor the representative were present for the hearing. Staff said that the Commission had received a memo from staff with a brief analysis and recommendations. Chairman Lambert discussed making an amendment to the Ranchaero Land Use Plan that would recognize the existing higher densities to the north of the Ranchaero Airport., There was a brief discussion. Chairman Lambert asked about an avigation easement. Staff stated that basically the avigation easement covers noise, safety and building heights. Henry Roberson, Manager of.Ranchaero Airport, stated that he was not in opposition to the development because there are other developments.already in place that are closer to the end of the runways. He said. that avigation easements should be considered and that he hopes the Commission is aware that each development does have an effect on the airport. Chairman Lambert stated that the Commission needs to make a strong statement in the Ranchaero Plan that the Commission's intent is to not go beyond Glenwood and that they have made a modification of the flight pattern to help mitigate developers 2 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - June 8, 1988 that are bound to be approved because of the zoning and general plan that has been previously approved. Commissioner Stevens said that . she opposes the project development. Commissioner Gerst asked if there was anything documented in deeds that people are subject to noise, etc. Staff said that the recordation of avigation easement serves as a document in a title report. Commissioner Gerst said that he agreed with Mr. Roberson!s comments and that if this development is an impact to the Airport, in which it is, it just compounds and that he could not support the development at this time. Chairman Lambert asked what the time line schedule was with the Advisory Agency on this map. Staff briefly discussed the time line schedule and said that a months delay could create a problem and that the Commission ask that this project not go forward until such time a decision is made regarding the potential impact. Staff said that the Commission would not be approving or denying this project, but that they are recommending or suggesting. Staff also said that if the Commission is going to delay this project for further study, the.Environmental Branch should be notified of direction to what is happening and -why. It was moved by Commissioner Stevens, seconded by Commissioner Boness and unanimously, carried to ,find that- there might be potential impacts to the Airport that should be addressed in the enviornmental documents and recommend that an avigation easement be granted to the owner of the Ranchaero Airport and that a decision on the recommendation as to whether the project should be approved or denied and placed on the July 13, 1988 agenda. 3. Status Report - Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan Review There was nothing new to report, but was agreed to keep this item. on the agenda for the next meeting. 4. Status Report - Paradise Airport and Ranchaero Airport Environs and Airport Zoning Q BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION ' MINUTES - June 8, 1988 Staff -stated that there was more ,interest in rezoning the area south of Paradise. Staff also said,,that the Commission needed to get the Airport'Zone going for.both Paradise and Chico Airport. 5., AZ Code Amendment Chairman' Lambert said that she,' Commissioner Walter and Dave Hironimus have met as a Committee.on_,this project, and.that there was.nothing yet.to report: The Commission agreed to, carry this project forward to the July _ 13, 1988 meeting.' Chairman Lambert said that she "would welcome any comments regarding the AZ Code. 6. Business from the Floor ` There was no business from the Floor. VI•. CORRESPONDENCE' No correspondence VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES Chairman Lambert asked if Staff could send a letter regarding a vacant position.to the City.Selection Committee. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be July 13, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 10:12ta.m. N NA LAMBERT, Chairman. Airport Land Use Commission /jmc 4 BUTTE'COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - April 13, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:05 a.m. on April 13, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center; 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Walter, Boness, Franklin, and Chairman Lando Staff: Dave Hironimus, Jill Cervantes , III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Boness and unanimously carried to approve the minutes of the February 10, 1988 meeting as written. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no'items 'to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1. Discussion - Statement of Economic Interest Forms Dave reminded the Commission that if their Statement of Economic Forms were not turned in already that they should do so. 2. Status Report - Paradi Environs and Airport Z )ort Environs Ranchaero Airport Dave said that enclosed in each Commissioners' packet there was a draft of an alternate airport zone that was submitted to the Planning Commission by Commissioner Lambert for consideration. Dave said that the Planning Commission formed a Committee of both Commissioners Lambert and Walter to study the draft prepare proposals. Commissioner Walter mentioned that he and Commissioner Lambert have not gotten together to review the draft, and asked if anyone on the ALUC Commission had any comments. Chairman Lando said that he did review the draft and that he would like to see the wide range of industrial uses be allowed under Use Permits, and make sure that "Special Provisions" be a standard. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPO&LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - April 13 988 Page 2 ..Dave said that'staff.has been getting the Chico, Oroville and Paradise plans ready for'publication. 3. Status Report.- Chico Municipal Airport Environs -Plan Review There was nothing to report. r 4. Review of City of Oroville General Plan Conformity `- Oroville Municipal Airport Environs Dave said that'he was able to obtain a map from the City of Oroville illustrating the new'thresholds adopted. There -was a brief discussion on the differences of clear zones as'shown on the adopted Oroville- .Land Use Plan vs. the clear zones resulting from relocated thresholds. Dave discussed.brief ly the necessity of revising the Oroville Land Use Plans. ' Dave mentioned that afiy funding set aside for the'Airport Land Use 'Commission/Planning/Airport improvements can also be'used for clear - zone acquisitions. 5. Business from the Floor - There was no.business from the,floor. "':VI. CORRESPONDENCE 'No correspondence , VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES There were no , referrals to staff and/or formation of committees. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The'meeting-schedule was discussed and was pointed out that the schedule could not be changed unless the ByLaws were -amended. The next meeting will -be May ll, 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 9:20 a.m. _74- ..TOM LANDO,.Chairman •' Airport Land Use Commission /jmc t • Rte. . ' BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES -.February 10, 1988 The meeting of the'Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:01 a.m. on February 10, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room,'County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. 6. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Lambert, Stevens, Walter, and Chairman Lando Staff: Dave Hironimus, Brent Moore, Susan Sears III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES i It was moved by Commissioner Stevens, seconded by Commissioner Lambert and unanimously carried to approve the minutes of the January 13, 1988 meeting as written. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. V. BUSINESS 1_ Public Hearinn - Ranchaero Airport Environs Plan Mr. Hironimus summarized the draft plan review process. The hearing was opened to the public. 'No one was present to speak to this item. The hearing was closed to -the 'public. Commissioner Walter asked, with regard to the statement on Page 14 relating to acquisition of clear zones, if any action is being -taken. Mr.-Hironimus replied that this is a contingency for the 20 -year life' expectancy of the plan, and that such actio_ns'aren't appropriate at the present time. Commissioner Lambert asked if avigation easements are acquired at present; Mr. Hironimus said yes, in conjunction with current developments. , Commissioner Walter asked if avigation easements are currently -in place at the north end of the airport, where some people have registered protests. Mr. Hironimus referred to the map posted on the wall showing the present locations of subdivisions and orchards, adding that Greenline policies indicate the retention of the orchards as an agricultural use. Commissioner Walter expressed concern about the urban areas. Mr. Hironimus said that avigation easements are obtained at the time of development; however, with presently -developed BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORTPAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - February 10, 1988 Page 2 land, it's difficult to go back and pick them up. The new Zoning Code currently under consideration would include overlay zones, and the -Airport Environs overlay zone would address avigationjeasements. Chairman Lando asked about the "C2" which appears in the third paragraph on Page 14. Mr. Hironimus said he thought this might be a typographical error and said he would take a look at it. Commissioner Lambert suggested that the table which begins on Page 16 could be made more user-friendly, and Mr. Hironimus said he would re -work it. Mr. Hironimus introduced Brent Moore to the Commission. Mr. Moore told the Commission about his background and experience in planning and his emphasis in airport -related issues, including the drafting of the Aviation Improvement Act (SB 263). It was moved by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Commissioner Walter and unanimously carried, as follows: A. Find that the requirements of CEOA have been completed and considered in making this decision and adopt a Negative Declaration; and B. Find that the draft Ranchaero Airport Environs Land Use Plan meets the requirements•of California Public Utilities Code Section 21675; and C. Adopt the Ranchaero Airport Environs Land Use Plan pursuant to Public Utilities Code Sections 21674 and 21675, and including the revisions requested at this meeting. 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport Environs Mr. Hironimus said there have'been no changes in the Town's prezoning at this point, so there is nothing new to report. 3. Commercial Airport Zoning - Discussion Mr. Hironimus said that with Airport Land Use Plans now adopted for all four public -use airports, ALUC could ask the Planning Commission to adopt a Commercial Airport zoning district, to facilitate these airports' operations. Ranchaero, for instance, is an existing nonconforming use under its present zoning. Commissioner Lambert asked if this proposed zone is being discussed today; Mr. Hironimus said the actual discussion should be conducted by the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors and that ALUC should simply say such a zone is needed. Commissioner Walter commented that at the present time the County's zoning code is being simplified and many zones are being eliminated. With a special zone for airports, should there also be a zone for hospitals, schools, etc.? Mr. Hironimus suggested that perhaps the PO Zone could be modified to include airport uses. BUTTE 'COUNTY AIRPORT %ND USE COMMISSION • MINUTES - February 10, 1988 Page 3 Chairman Lando said the zoning should allow airport -related uses such as fixed -base operators,'related offices, restaurants and the like. It was moved by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Commissioner Stevens and unanimously carried, to recommend that the Butte County Planning Commission initiate zoning for the Paradise and Ranchaero Airports. Henry Roberson stated he wants to expand Ranchaero's operations to .include compatible businesses and wanted to know if he should make application to ALUC. Chairman Lando suggested he write to the Planning Commission in support of the motion just passed by ALUC. 4. SB 263 - Discussion 4 Brent Moore said the bill passed the Senate two weeks ago. Opposition came from the larger metropolitan areas, so the bill was changed somewhat; however, locals still do gain some autonomy. The bill calls for a new process to plan for and establish the need for airports. There is virtually no input at the local level, so one of the bill's aims is to improve this. Taking jet fuel taxes from the State's general fund would yield $110 million per year "in a good year" and this money would be earmarked for airports. Every airport would receive $10,000 per year, plus there would be funding for ALUCs statewide, a total of 1.5 million for the entire state. Metropolitan Planning Organizations or Councils of Governments would be funded for the preparation of Regional Aviation System Plans and would work with the ALUCs in developing these plans. Included would be a ten-year capital improvement plan for all airports in the County. Then, a statewide plan which coordinates these county plans would be done, and hearings would be conducted before the California Transportation Commission prior to allocations being made to the airports. Another benefit of this bill is it should help the State stay within its Gann spending limit. Chairman Lando asked what the effect would be on the County's general fund. Mr. Moore said only the State's share of jet fuel sales tax is affected. Commissioner Lambert asked, does the money go to the Counties? Mr. Moore said it would go to the ALUCs. Then, each ALUC, through participation in the Overall Work Program, would establish its own goals. Commissioner Lambert asked when the Overall Work Program is submitted, Mr. Moore said sometime in March. This ALUC's first opportunity to participate would be in Marchlof 1989. Chairman Lando asked if Butte would receive much funding; Mr. Moore said Butte should be competitive since he himself had written the bill and feels we have "the inside edge." BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORTOND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - February 10, 1988 Page 4 Commissioner Walter asked if this only applies to jet fuel; Mr. Moore said non -jet fuel taxes are already going into an aviation account. Jet fuel is the least political vehicle; ad valorem taxes, for example, meet with heavy opposition. Mr. Moore said he anticipates that there should be good Assembly support for this bill, and the Governor's office likes it. Commissioner Lambert pointed out that $10,000 per year would be double what the city airports presently receive. Mr. Moore added that with the ten-year capital improvement plan,ia year is added each year (and a year dropped) . Commissioner Walter wondered how this would mesh With the Regional Transportation Plan; Mr. Moore said the RTP is supposed to,have an aviation section in it. Mr. Hironimus asked about public vs. private airports; Mr. Moore said the original bill would have funded private airports as well, but it's hard to avoid making a gift of public funds so special stipulations would have to be in place. In order to be funded, airports must be in the plan and documented, and be included within the regional system plan as well. Commissioner Lambert asked if a letter of support would be helpful; Mr. Moore said yes, to Senator Neilsen and Assemblymember Chandler. It was the consensus of the Commission .to have Mr. Hironimus prepare the 'letters. 5. Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan - Discussion Mr. Hironimus said the plan is ten years old now and needs updating; he directed the Commission's attention to the review prepared by Mr. Moore and included in the packets for today's meeting. Chairman Lando asked how the process will work; Mr. Hironimus suggested the formation of an ALUC committee, adding that if SB 263 passes all of our plans will need to be extensively revised but that funding would then be available to staff these projects. Chairman Lando expressed his interest in serving on the committee. Mr. Moore suggested that the committee should develop a concise and orderly public -participation program. Chairman Lando asked for volunteers. Commissioner Stephens, not present at today's meeting, was suggested as a possible member; also Brent Moore as a staff member. 6. City Referrals of Airport -related Projects - Discussion Mr. Hironimus said that PUC Section 21676 (a,b,c) requires that cities' General Plan Amendments, zoning ordinances or building regulations within airport planning boundaries must be referred to the ALUC. At present, cities have requested ALUC's input because they want it, but this is voluntary -on the part of the cities. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORTOND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - February 10, 1988 Page 5 Chairman Lando asked if this includes building codes; Mr. Hironimus said yes, insofar as they relate to height limits, coverage requirements, etc. Commissioner Lambert commented that the City of Oroville's General Plan is not in conformance with the adopted Airport Land Use Plan. Mr. Hironimus said it may be out of conformance, In light of the City's recent action to change its runway thresholds. Commissioner Lambert suggested that projects could be referred to ALUC until all the cities' General Plans are in conformance, adding that ALUC should still require the 4/5 vote by a city to override, along with appropriate findings for overriding. Chairman Lando said he'd like to see a modified process, so that ALUC doesn't become another layer of government. He suggested that staff could make the determination as to whether ALUC needs to review a particular project. He asked if a motion would be in order. Mr. Hironimus said a policy statement could.come out of the Commission, giving staff the authority to review projects. Commissioner Stevens asked if staff would prepare the proposed policy change. Chairman Lando requested this be placed on the March meeting agenda. The meeting was adjo ned at 110:00 a.m. TOM LANDO, haIrman Airport Land Use Commission /sjs E BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USEiCOMMISSION MINUTES - January •13, 1988 The meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:10 a.m. on January 13, 1988, in the Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. u I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners=Franklin, Stevens, Walter,.and Vice Chairman Lambert. Staff: Dave Hironimus, Planner; Jill.Cervantes, Secretary% III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Stevens to approve the minutes of December 9, 1987. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: Commissioners Franklin, Stevens and Walter NOES: No one ' ABSENT: Commissioner Harvey and Chairman Lando ABSTAINED: Vice Chairman Lambert IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed V. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Ranchaero ALUP Dave Hironimus said that the initial study has been completed and is going through the Clearinghouse for review. He said that the review, ends January 20, 1988 and that he anticipates the project clearing the Clearinghouse without any ma,jor.comments to be addressed and -'plans to publish the project so that it could be heard at the February meeting. He said that if there were any items that would have to. be addressed, the hearing could be continued if necessary. He said that he would work on a mailing list and then publish accordingly. Dave said that once the plan is adopted, the Commission could work at getting the appropriate zoning on the'airport property. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORIWAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES`- January 13, 1988 Page 2 Dave Hironimis said that once the Ranchaero Plan is adopted, he is intending to set up the zoning for the airport property for both Ranchaero and Paradise at the same time. He said he would like to hear both projects at the same time before the.Planning Commission. He said that there could possibly be an agenda item for the February meeting to recommend such an'action to the Planning Commission and that this Commission may,not want to take action pending the outcome of Ranchaero Airport. 2_ Status Report - Paradise Airport Environs Dave Hironimus said that he had been in contact with Steve,Smi.th from the Town of Paradise, and that he said the prezone south of Paradise is on hold. He said that they will wait for the code amendment to,go through for the county zoning before applying height restriction in the form.of an overlay.zone. Specific zoning for the airport property will take place at the same time as Ranchaero Airport zoning. 3. Business from the Floor The Commission requested that staff Put the following items on the agenda for the February meeting. 1. Form a Committee for review of the Chico Municipal Airport Environs Plan. 2. Discussion - When.do cities bring,airport related -actions to ALUC prior to city actions.. VI. CORRESPONDENCE No correspondence VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES There were no referrals to staff and/or formation of committees. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be February 10,. 1988. The meeting was adjourned at 9:30 a.m. FRED DAVIS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission b Nina Lambert, Vice Chairman' /jmc BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 9, 1987 y The'meeting of the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) was called to order at 9:00 a.m. on.December 9, 1987, in the Board of -Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County -Center Drive, Oroville, California. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL Present:.- Commissioners. -Franklin, Stevens, Walter, Roberson and Chairman Lando. Staff: Dave Hironimus, Planner; Jill Cervantes, Secretary. Also in Attendance: Mary Ann Imbiorski, City of Oroville, Gerry DeRoco, and Fred Gerst. III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Stevens and unanimously carried, to approve the minutes of the November 4, 1987 ALUC meeting as written. Commissioner Walter briefly discussed,-the-Oroville Airport Radio Beacon. IV. CONSENT AGENDA There were no items to be discussed. il V. BUSINESS 1. Status Report - Ranchaero Airport Land Use Plan Dave Hironimus stated he plans to have the initi•al,study for the Ranchaero Airport Land Use Plan ready for typing possibly today. 2. Status Report - Paradise Airport•Environs Dave Hironimus stated that there was nothing new,to'report on the Paradise Airport Environs. He stated that staff'is still waiting for any actions from'the Town of Paradise on their Prezone which is in the same area. 3. Status Report - Oroville'Airport Environs Dave Hironimus stated that the Orovil-le Airport General Plan does not match the County's Airport Land Use Plan and that under the Public Utilities Code, Section 21676.5, the Commission could require the City to forward all development plans, permits, etc., to this Commission for review until such time their General Plan is brought into conformity with the Airport Land Use Plan. He stated that this.has not been done in the past because they have been trying to get things 1 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 9, 1987 Page 2 worked out. He stated that at this point the City has been referring their projects to this Commission. He stated that basically as a responsible agency under CEOA, this Commission has been commenting accordingly, and that the findings that have been made really have no effect other than comments from a responsible agency. He stated that under Section 21676, if the Commission requires the City to forward their plans, the Commission has a situation of the City choosing whether override to the ALUC decision by a four-fifths vote. Chairman Lando stated that he does not object and that he feels the Commission should reinforce their concerns regarding the Oroville Airport. He stated that he felt it was the Commission's job to push all airport plans and that the Commission should again indicate their concern and point out the sections of the Code. Dave Hironimus confirmed that the Commission should then ask the City to forward projects for comments but not take it to the next step for overruling findings. Commissioner Walter briefly discussed the relocation of the airport runway thresholds. 4. Review of Use Permit for Aztec Development, AP#030-23-0-139,140 Dave Hironimus stated that most of the Commission's concerns were related to the clear zones and really the Commission has to review noise impacts, security considerations and avigation easement grants. Gerry DeRoco stated that he would like to see applicants receive notices of hearings. He stated that he understood that the approach zones will basically have the same requirements. Dave Hironimus stated that projects in an approach zone might run into a building height problem, but there are not the same restrictions in terms of development standards as there are in clear zones. He stated that this project would be going into a Safety Area 1 instead of a Safety Area 2. Chairman Lando questioned what exactly was the Use Permit for. Dave Hironimus stated that Aztec Development applied for a Use Permit for a return to custody facility. He also stated that at the September meeting, the finding was made that it had appeared the project would be in conformity with the plan, but that no final finding was going to be made until such time as the Commission had all information from a Use Permit application, which had not been made at that time. He stated that the Commission received the information from the City in time for the November meeting and that it was heard at that point. He stated that a motion of intent was adopted, but that no findings were formally made, and that information was submitted to the City. He stated that the item was continued to the December meeting, and since that time, changes in the threshold positioning had taken place, so the original motion of intent is no longer appropriate. He stated that the Commission is looking at the recommendation staff has prepared. BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 9, 1987• 'Page 3 Chairman Lando stated he felt that staff reports.should be mailed to all applicants. , It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and unanimously carried to find that the proposed Use Permit for Aztec Development conforms to the policies of the Oroville Airport Land Use Plan and recommend that any City approval be made conditional upon the following: 1. Noi,se impacts should be addressed in the environmental documents and a survey of the site performed to'determine what building construction standards should be required. 2. Security'considerations should be'addressed in the event of aircraft incident or accident on the property and the availability and response capabilities of emergency services on the property. 3. Grant an avigation easement to the City of Oroville. 5. Review of Use Permit -for Paul-Farris.-AP#030-21-1-26 Commissioner Roberson asked how long a time is allowed for temporary second dwellings. Dave HM-ronimus stated that they were.open-ended and that the County's procedure is that they allow a mobile home as a temporary second dwelling`,for people who require close care. He stated that this kind of project is put through the Use Permit process, and that there is a requirement, when the second unit is no longer needed, that it be removed from the property or converted into a non-residential use. He stated that there is a requirement.for a bond or deposit to guarantee the removal of,the second dwelling unit. ,I It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Franklin 7 and unanimously carried to,find that,.although the project will result in densities greater than those recommended by the Oroville Airport Environs Land Use Plan, the -use will be temporary and will not be overly exposed to aircraft hazards due to the existence of substantial open space nearby, most notably the Oroville Wildlife Area approximately 1/8 mile to the southeast. 6. Review of School Site in the Ranchaero Area Dave Hironimus stated that the proposed school site is out of the traffic patterns and is within one mile of the airport. There was a brief discussion on school sites and how far they should be away from airports. , Chairman Lando stated that he was sympathetic with a school at that site. It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Commissioner Franklin and carried to -find the proposed school site -conforms to the policies of the draft Ranchaero Airport Environs Land Use Plan as follows: 9 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 9, 1987 Page 4 AYES: Commissioners Walter, Stevens, Franklin, and Chairman'Lando NOES: No one ABSENT: Commissioner Lambert ABSTAINED: Commissioner Roberson 7. Review of Rezone for Drake/Jeffries. AP#048-02-0-049 Chairman Lando stated that this Rezone was a request to change the designation of the property from Limited Manufacturing Industrial Park to Limited Manufacturing with the same conditions. He stated that he did not see any substantial change in the proposed use. Dave Hironimus briefly discussed the location of the project. He stated that the Commission would not like to see large concentrations of people in the flight corridor area, but that he suspects that the City will limit that problem because of setbacks from the creek and other factors. There was a brief discussion on the location and flight. corridor area. It was moved by Commissioner Franklin, seconded by'Commissioner Walter and unanimously•carried to find the proposed rezone compatible with the Airport Env -irons Land Use Plan only if the project is conditioned so that no storage of inflammables or .other dangerous materials, or large concentrations of people are allowed under the flight corridor as a result of subsequent development. ' 8. Review of Prezone for Rick Coletti AP#048-03-3-010 Dave Hironimus stated that this project was just barely under the edges of the pri.m'ary surface for review and that it was sent for review by the City of Chico. It was moved by Commissioner Walter, seconded by Franklin and unanimously carried to find the proposed prezone in conformity with the Airport Environs Plan only if development of the property is no greater than six dwelling units per acre. 9. Election of Second Vice Chairman Criteria for Second Vice Chairman were discussed, and since Commissioner Stevens was the only Commissioner that met the criteria, she was elected by acclamation. 10. Business from the Floor There was no business from the floor. VI. CORRESPONDENCE 11 BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION MINUTES - December 9, 1987 Page 5 Dave Hironimus handed out a copy of the.Public Utilities Code, and stated that the new Legislation has been adopted. He stated that he talked with the people of Division of Aeronautics and that they stated there are no changes in the form, except that it does not have -adopti,on dates or effective dates, and that'it will become effective at the first of the year. He stated -that the biggest effect was that the appointees by the Airport Managers' Association are now required to have expertise in aviation. He stated that there was still -no, requirement for the alternatives to have that same expertise. VII. REFERRALS TO STAFF AND FORMATION OF COMMITTEES There were no referrals to staff and/or formation of committees. VIII. ANNOUNCEMENTS The next meeting will be January 13, 1987. The meeting was adjourned at 9:47 a.m. FRED DAVIS, Chairman Airport Land Use Commission y Tom Lando, Altern e /jmc M